Pitchers & Catchers

Scenes 26 min

Next Door Buddies

Pitchers & Catchers

Cast: Samuel O'Toole James Jamesson Tyler Ford Paul Wagner
Release date: 2010-11-11
Runtime: 26 min
Studio: Next Door Buddies
Tags: Amateur Brown Hair Deepthroat Fraternity Gay Hardcore Jockstrap Masturbation Orgy Red Hair Tattoos White anal blonde_hair blowjob outdoor
Code: 25277

Paul Wagner, Samuel O'Toole, James Jamesson & Tyler Ford were spotted playing a game of catch this last weekend. It's hard to say which one is the best looking because they're all so damn hot. Tones muscles, sexy faces and fat cocks. What's not to love!? When the heat of the sun was too much for the 4, it was time to head indoors. Once inside, the 4 strip down and get ready for shower time. But before they all rinsed off, they decided to get a bit more dirty. Enjoy!

My rating, notes & lists

My rating

Sources StashDB 2026-10-05

Wrong information or a problem with this page? Tell us about wrong details, duplicates or illegal content.

More with this cast

Multiple Options2013-03-21+2026-10-05

Vinny Castillo, Samuel O'Toole, James Huntsman, James Jamesson, Cameron Foster, Johnny Torque +1 others Next Door Buddies Scenes

Summer Games2012-12-08+2026-10-05

Samuel O'Toole, James Jamesson, Jett Jax Samuel O'Toole Scenes

The White Party2012-06-09+2026-10-05

Samuel O'Toole, James Jamesson, Brody Wilder Samuel O'Toole Scenes

The Guys Next Door, Part 1, Scene 22011-10-21+2026-10-05

Samuel O'Toole, Paul Wagner Falcon Studios Scenes

More with this performer

Eat The Rich: Mutual Interest – Ryan Orion, Johnny Donovan, And Paul Wagner2026-09-23+2026-10-06

Ryan Orion, Paul Wagner, Johnny Donovan NakedSword Scenes

Eat the Rich: Double Dipping – Jayden Marcos and Paul Wagner2026-09-03+2026-10-06

Jayden Marcos, Paul Wagner NakedSword Scenes

Bred & Breakfast: Push It Inn, Scene 32025-12-19+2026-10-06

Paul Wagner, Sir Peter Falcon Studios Scenes

Wild Game - Scene 52025-10-08+2026-10-06

Blain O'Connor, Jayden Marcos, Paul Wagner, Derek Kage NakedSword × Disruptive Films Scenes

Wild Game - Scene 22025-09-17+2026-10-06

Heath Halo, Paul Wagner NakedSword × Disruptive Films Scenes

Paul Wagner Breeds Rustin Peace2024-01-19+2026-10-05

Levi Michaels, Paul Wagner Reality Dudes Scenes

Paul Wagner Hooks Up with Holden Flex2023-12-22+2026-10-05

Paul Wagner, Holden Flex Reality Dudes Scenes

Overdrive, Scene 52023-10-27+2026-10-05

Sean Xavier, Paul Wagner Raging Stallion Scenes

Same studio

See all

Gamer Bros2026-11-11+2026-11-12

Kit Thorne, Vincent Grey Next Door Buddies Scenes

Fantasy Cum True2026-09-19+2026-10-06

Kyler Drayke, Kyle Fletcher Next Door Buddies Scenes

Let Me Help2026-08-29+2026-10-06

Damen Wesley, Johnny Donovan Next Door Buddies Scenes

Shower Buddies2026-08-15+2026-10-06

Eddie Patrick, Jayden Marcos Next Door Buddies Scenes

Work Break2026-06-24+2026-10-06

Ricky Lee, Johnny Donovan Next Door Buddies Scenes

Nice Dick, Bro2026-06-20+2026-10-06

Vincent Grey, Seth Peterson Next Door Buddies Scenes

Member Fantasies: Break Me In2026-06-03+2026-10-06

Colton Nash, Noah Asli Next Door Buddies Scenes

Take It To The Showers2026-05-09+2026-10-06

Xavier Zane, Jayden Marcos Next Door Buddies Scenes

Similar scenes

Towel Wipping Fun2010-10-21+2026-10-05

Tyler Ford, Paul Wagner Next Door Buddies Scenes

Shower & Sex2010-06-03+2026-10-05

James Jamesson, Paul Wagner Next Door Buddies Scenes

Brunch Or Orgy?2010-06-17+2026-10-05

Rod Daily, Phenix Saint, Parker London, Paul Wagner Next Door Buddies Scenes

Horny Photoshot2010-07-29+2026-10-05

Rod Daily, Paul Wagner Next Door Buddies Scenes

The Muse Excuse2011-01-27+2026-10-05

Hunter Vance, Paul Wagner Next Door Buddies Scenes

Sammy Gets Caught Spying On The Neighbors2010-12-23+2026-10-05

Rod Daily, Samuel O'Toole, Parker London Next Door Buddies Scenes

Welcuming A First Timer2010-11-09+2026-10-05

Nate Kennedy, Samuel O'Toole, Zach Alexander Samuel O'Toole Scenes

Deep In The Ass2010-07-01+2026-10-05

Chad Con, Samuel O'Toole Next Door Buddies Scenes